DOCUMENTARY
MODES
This
mode of documentary is what most viewers will recognize. Verbal
commentary is critical to this form of documentary, as well as an
assertiveness in its claims, often voiced by a narrator with an
authoritative tone. The expository mode is often found in television
news programming.
The
expository mode of documentary filmmaking chooses an argument, and a
"right" answer with a preferred meaning. This is often
directly addressed to the audience, the point is clear and concise
and the narrator does not encourage the viewer to question the
conclusion.
John
Grierson's work is a good example of the use of the expository mode
of documentary filmmaking. Many nature documentaries employ this
mode.
Think of someone exposing themselves as "natural" to remember that the expository mode is used a lot in "nature" documentaries. Or think of a less gross way to remember.
Nudist BBQ = Expository mode of documentary film making. Obvious connection. |
The
Poetic Mode
- (subjective, artistic expression).
The
poetic mode of documentary shies away from the "objective"
reality of a certain situation or people to gain an "inner
truth" that can only be attained by poetic manipulation. It
emphasizes descriptive passages, rhythmic or tonal qualities, visual
associations and favours mood, tone and texture.
A
good example of the use of the poetic mode in documentary is "Man
of Aran" (1934) by Robert J. Flaherty. It employs dramatic
framing and presents an exaggerated image of a man at one with
nature.
Leni
Riefenstahl's "Olympia" (1938) represents the Aryan
athletes during the Olympic Games of 1936 as successful, beautiful
and perfect - all exaggerated highly to excessively promote the Aryan
race.
Not to be confused with downright lying. Although Robert J. Flaherty has been given (a little too leniently) the excuse of employing the "poetic mode" of documentary film making, I'm certain that if someone studied the law extensively enough, they could find a clause that meant anyone who has ever seen "Nanook of the North" could sue Flaherty for being a fraudulent, lying (expletive).
I will be devoting an entire article to this big fat lie later. |
The
Performative Mode
- (the film maker actively participates during the filming)
This
mode of documentary particularly focuses on the subjective nature of
the documentarian and also acknowledges the fact that the audience
can view the film subjectively. The idea of objectivity is replaced
by "evocation and affect"
This
mode accentuates the emotional and social impact on the audience.
Michael Moore adopts the performative mode in a lot of his work.
An
example of the performative mode is Morgan Spurlock's "Supersize
Me" (2004).
The
Reflexive Mode
The
reflexive mode recognizes the constructive attributes of the
documentary, but does not hide it. It admits to the viewer that this
is not necessarily the "truth" but an accurate
representation of it -"a" truth not "the" truth.
The
artifice of the documentary is not hidden, the audience is well aware
of the editing, sound, recording and reconstructions - many of which,
are often used in this mode. There are even times where see the film
being constructed within the film.
Dziga
Vertov's "Man With A Camera" (1929) presents the
industrialization of Soviet life in the late 1920's. The mechanical
camera and the cameraman become part of the content.
The
Observational Mode
The
Observational mode of documentary film making is best exemplified by
the Cinema Verite (aka the Direct Cinema Movement) which developed in
the late 1950's/early 1960's in an attempt to record objective
reality as accurately as possible, with the film maker as an unbiased
observer. The film maker is a witness rather than a participant.
The
filmmaker is hidden behind the camera, does not interact with the
characters being filmed and is ignored by the subjects. The filmmaker
does therefore not influence the actions of the subjects and the
events being captured.
In
the observational mode, nothing is staged or set up and the camera
has to rush sometimes to keep up with the action-taking place. This
sometimes results in shaky, amateur looking footage, a great
disadvantage to using the mode of documentary making.
A
good example of this mode is Frederick Wiseman's "Hospital"
(1970), which aimed to capture the daily drama of a hospital as
accurately as possible.
Richard
Pennebacker's "Don't Look Back" (1967) is also a good
example of this mode, in recording Bob Dylan's 1965 tour of Britain.
The
Participatory Mode:
In
total contrast to the observational mode, the participatory mode embraces
direct interaction between the filmmaker and the characters of the
documentary
The
filmmaker openly becomes part of the events being captured. The
filmmaker's influence on the events is acknowledged and is often also
celebrated.
Michael
Moore often adopts the participatory mode in his work, he openly
engages with the characters, and essentially becomes a character
during the filming.
Martin
Bashir's "Living With Michael Jackson" (2003) is an example
of the participatory mode being used.
As
is "Kurt and Courtney" (1998) by Nick Broomfield (who often
adopts the participatory mode in his work.)
Louis Theroux antagonizing everyone he comes into contact with while making his documentaries is another example of the participatory mode.
As is John Sweeney huffing and puffing during filming "Scientology and Me" appearing to be trying to blow the interviewee's house down.
"On the other hand..." |
As is John Sweeney huffing and puffing during filming "Scientology and Me" appearing to be trying to blow the interviewee's house down.
"YOU SHALL NOT PASS!!!" |
No comments:
Post a Comment